poplar vs basswood

For a prime example, look how many "signature" guitars/amps/sfx there are out there. MAIN USES Light construction, furniture, kitchen cabinets, doors, paneling, moulding and millwork, edge-glued panels, turnings, and carvings John Suhr says good things about basswood with a maple cap, if your into his builds. Some Poplars are also called Basswood, Linden Trees are best known as Basswood. The table below provides laboratory values for several properties of wood that are associated with wood strength. Poplar is a medium-density wood with low-bending, shock resistance, stiffness, and compression values. Basswood and Poplar are technically hardwoods. A lot of the mythos regarding "tonewoods" comes from the acoustic guitar world, where it does make a substantial difference. Poplar Shutters. It’s critical to note, though, that the material is in some cases vulnerable to breakage. Yes. As far as the softness and durability of the wood, well my tastes have changed in the last few years and have become more old and "country" in flavour. It was introduced by sauna companies because of its similar appearance to Poplar in an attempt to copy High Tech Health saunas. All other workable and mechanical properties of basswood are equal to or superior to poplar. Basswood and Poplar are two of the more common woods used to make interior shutters. Basswood: the principal wood used on many Japanese made instruments. Some is surprising, although I think these may be averages or a single sample as I feel a lot is determined by where and how the tree grew. Poplar is one of the softest/lightest hardwoods, ranking down with Basswood. any good at all? But basswood is a good tonewood by any standards, and it has been used by many high-end makers with excellent results. So, when a piece in basswood gets dinged and dented, well that's one more notch in the "loved and cherished" scorecard. When it comes to timber shutters, Poplar is the best choice in the strength department over something like Basswood or other types of timbers. I agree but if no-one wants it what do I do. Basswood dents easier. Some kid wants to play like Eric Johnson or Steve Vai, what's he gonna do? ... Poplar Shutters. Interesting info Mack. Wouldn't it be nice if lumber was named after the tree it came from? Aspen is a true poplar, though the wood isn't used much for woodworking. Arrowhead Woodproducts, a Northern Mn company will be at the Charlotte Woodcarvers Show in February, 2021 with basswood for sale. What passes for Poplar in North America comes from the Tuliptree, a different species. Basswood Beech Birches Buckeye 2 Butternut Cottonwood Elms Hackberry Hemlocks Hickories Magnolia Maples Oak (red and black species) 2 Pines (most other species) 2 Poplar Spruces Sweetgum 2 Sycamore Willows Yellow-poplar. They seem to hold up OK. Poplar is one of the softest/lightest hardwoods, ranking down with Basswood. Quote from: Skyforger on August 07, 2013, 11:36:20 AM, Quote from: Cagey on August 07, 2013, 12:09:27 PM. It ranks decently in terms of strength, durability and ability to withstand decay but it does tend to be soft and porous, which means it doesn’t hold up well to the kinds of temperature extremes involved in sauna use. With our last wood hardness chart, several noted that there were certain woods missing that should be in the list, so we’ve expanded the list to 224 different species. ... Poplar. Hi Bill; depending on the species of pine, it ranges from 380 -- 740 more or less. Heck, how many designers have spent hours and $'s to develop old distressed finishes? Also, Basswoods virtually knot … Basswood takes a finish well; it can be either painted or stained. IMHO your second statement summed it up... "I always thought of basswood as being good for carving, and too soft for casework. That’s where you come in. I will keep the logs and offer it to local people. Some of the best wood types you need to know include cedar, poplar, basswood, fir, and hemlock. Basswood Vs Cedar VS Hemlock VS Poplar: Best Sauna Wood Type Comparison Comparing sauna wood types is a little tricky if you're talking to a sauna salesman. A & M woods sells it in only the 1 inch size. On the plus side, it's pretty smooth stuff - kinda like Alder. My wife points out that the 2 basswood are more like 75' not 100' and I am such a typical guy to overestimate the length. Anybody ever used bass for firewood? Basswood is a lighter weight wood normally producing Strat bodies under 4 lbs. Basswood is a great less expensive hardwood that mimics the sound of Maple to some, mahogany to others. is somewhat softer. https://www.facebook.com/pages/One-o...95203433854962, http://community.webshots.com/user/kcjones118. Yet it is more plentiful and gives the manufacturer a price advantage. Beautifull Mack. Not all woods are suitable for use in all parts of a guitar. Poplar guitars are ideal choices for players who favor single-coil snap and clean sound. Wood Density Chart in (103 kg/m3) / (lb/ft3) We would require to evaluate the hardness of wood, as wood is used in various uses such as furnitures and other industrial uses. All of which are … Premium Basswood is the best timber for constructing internal plantation shutters due to its lightweight and affordability, compared to fellow hardwoods Western Red Cedar, Maple or Oak. Basswood vs Poplar Carving. However, as with distinguishing yellow poplar (Liriodendron tulipifera) from Populus species, the difference can be seen in the rays when looking closely at the endgrain. I feel the finish Ibanez uses is harder than the finish used by warmoth. Jim … Poplar – as one of the more common woods in most parts of the world, poplar is an attractive choice in terms of availability. That may help with the protection. It ranks decently in terms of strength, durability and ability to withstand decay but it does tend to be soft and porous, which means it doesn’t hold up well to the kinds of temperature extremes involved in sauna use. Some wood can just have that magic 'pop' to it, and others can be duds, even in the same species. In fact, yellow poplar is typically a blend of colors like white, yellow, and even green. With our last wood hardness chart, several noted that there were certain woods missing that should be in the list, so we’ve expanded the list to 224 different species. Wood Plantation Shutters: Basswood and Poplar. What types of woods are used for guitars? But, with electrics, most of that doesn't apply, or doesn't have enough impact to make it worth discussion in light of the more influential variables such as pickups, playing style, and amplification. In guitars, poplar comes with a similar tone to alder as well. On the plus side, it's pretty smooth stuff - kinda like Alder. The color is white, but often has nasty green mineral streaks in it. I stripped the pickguard screw holes out in the soft poplar body and repaired them many years ago. One of the first differences you’ll notice between the two is their density. But cedar stands a little taller when it comes to efficiency and performance. Mack -- Like you see on the front of the big trucks! Basswood is one of the least expensive sauna wood types on this list. I don't carve nor do I turn. The sound is better, however, when it comes to the upper mid-range. Poplar is like a cheaper form of maple or birch, whereas basswood is a cheaper form of mahogany or bubinga. But as hardwoods, they are light and relatively soft compared with other hardwoods such as Maple or Oak. Basswood takes a finish well; it can be either painted or stained. It has a medium steam-bending classification. The specific gravity of poplar woods ranges from 0.31 to 0.43. Take a look here. So I am buying a new Body and my two choices are basswood and poplar. Some of the best wood types you need to know include cedar, poplar, basswood, fir, and hemlock. Basswood and Poplar aren’t quite polar opposites, but they are very unalike. Poplar: one of the softer hardwoods, nicely resonant with a meaty tone. I have a '97 mexi strat on which I have replaced every single part except the body- which is probably 6 or 7 pieces of poplar glued together. Poplar specializes in mid and high frequencies, while basswood specializes in mids to lows. All of the woods mentioned above are best for your sauna. Poplar is … Basswood is a great less expensive hardwood that mimics the sound of Maple to some, mahogany to others. When it comes to timber shutters, Poplar is the best choice in the strength department over something like Basswood or other types of timbers. Is this list complete? Great prices – quality wood at the largest woodcarving show in the southeast. If need be I assume I can store the logs outside for a while. Poplar is like a cheaper form of maple or birch, whereas basswood is a cheaper form of mahogany or bubinga. Basswood and Poplar are technically hardwoods. It in many ways is an upgrade to luaan, or ramin and is often used as a core wood with a bit more of the lower register tone to it than realized out of maple. Basswood Basswood One of the major benefits of basswood is that it is free of harmful toxins and allergens that could bother users; when treated properly it is considered hypoallergenic. Like basswood, alder is a lightweight type of body wood with soft and condensed pores. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. I have to make some faceframes and rail/stile sets for some painted cupboards. This page was generated at 06:35 AM. I find the amount that I have worked with, is reasonably stable. The cupboards will be primarily for storage - i.e. Is this list complete? Any comments on either wood and also, for the bass wood, exactly how fragile is it? Poplar is just as strong and tough. Affordable and abundant, basswood is particularly associated with mid-level or budget guitars. Learn how to play like them? The Janka ratings for bigtooth aspen and quaking aspen are 420 and 350. I've heard it is better to split the logs rather than saw them for carving. Basswood Basswood is light, stiff, and stable, which makes it particularly effective for necks and bass instruments thanks to its excellent low-end response. Yellow Poplar: Perfect for Cream Plantation Shutters Yellow poplar is like the sister of basswood in that it has the same durability and lightness that makes it an ideal plantation shutter material, but is unique in that the color of yellow poplar wood isn’t a uniform color. I think these #'s should be used as relative rather than determinate ones. Besides, they can handle high temperatures and cracks. from jemsite.com - Basswood: Basswood is a soft wood with tight grains. The following pics are of a memory box made from Basswood I made and chip carved for my 8 going on 13 year old grandson. Mineral streaks and a green color make Poplar wood a poor choice for staining. Easy to work with. He's gonna buy the same equipment they use. It in many ways is an upgrade to luaan, or ramin and is often used as a core wood with a bit more of the lower register tone to it than realized out of maple. Yellow poplar is like the sister of basswood in that it has the same durability and lightness that makes it an ideal plantation shutter material, but is unique in that the color of yellow poplar wood isn’t a uniform color. Poplar specializes in mid and high frequencies, while basswood specializes in … Poplar woods are soft and white, with uniform texture and straight grain. Like alder, poplar is a type of wood that’s commonly used to manufacture many things. Basswood vs. Poplar If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. PVC is also a material that tends to have longevity on its side. PVC is also a material that tends to have longevity on its side. Some is surprising, although I think these may be averages or a single sample as I feel a lot is determined by where and how the tree grew. Besides, they can handle high temperatures and cracks. That’s where you come in. Many guitar manufacturers as a substitute for alder are using this wood, as it is quite similar in tone. Poplar – as one of the more common woods in most parts of the world, poplar is an attractive choice in terms of availability. Basswood (Tilia americana) The pale color and light weight closely matches aspen. Having seen your work I definatly promise to not burn or allow it to go to the dump. This is part of a series of videos using a guitar I built specifically for comparing tone wood and other components. Basswood and Poplar are two of the more common woods used to make interior shutters. It takes finish well (Watco). The Basswood tree can be found from Quebec south to Delaware and the Atlantic coast west to Eastern Kentucky with an average height of 65 feet. It was introduced by sauna companies because of its similar appearance to Poplar in an attempt to copy High Tech Health saunas. All times are GMT-5. AVAILABILITY Very widely available. Doesn't require as much prep to finish. All of the woods mentioned above are best for your sauna. Yellow poplar is only about 20% harder than basswood. Inspiring Media Inc. o/a Canadian Woodworking. I do know that many of the 80's RG's have chipped edges and that's most likely due to the Basswood. Poplar shutters mill and paints well. Cottonwoods are also taller, ranging between 80 and 200 feet, whereas the balsam poplar is only 80 feet and the black poplar a mere 40 to 50. Note that due to inadequacies of samples, these values may not necessarily represent average characteristics .Tree SpeciesAverage Specific Gravity, Oven Dry SampleStatic Bending Modulus of Elasticity (E)Impact Bending, Height of Drop Causing FailureCompress. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. Re: Body wood: Poplar vs. Alder Not too many years ago I called and spoke to one of the Fender guys about the alder vs poplar issue....I was told that Fender went back to alder on the MIMs because poplar was costlier at that time over the alder...I don't own a poplar body and so can't opinion on alder vs poplar.My strats/Teles are either alder,ash,or basswood(MIJ) model.. I have built many utiltarian cupboard doors from Bass. to be 410, & Pop. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. I also got guitars made of alder, mahogany, swamp ash. The table below provides laboratory values for several properties of wood that are associated with wood strength. There are a number of species commonly referred to as Basswood. it's a few months away so I will do more asking around. Basswood also boasts an excellent strength to weight ratio, and a density that is about 25 pounds per cubic foot. You're just as likely to find differences between different Poplar bodies as you are comparing them to a variety of Alder bodies. Hi Bill; yes I'm sure there are many factors. Basswood is much softer and lighter than Poplar, which makes cutting into it a cinch. It mills easily. Basswood has a peculiar odor that many people find objectionable, making it … If this is indeed what it says it is then poplar can look rather amazing too. It's normally finished opaque, as it often has green streaks that would interfere with most transparent finishes. Red maple is about twice as hard and yellow birch is about three times as hard. Hi Bill; that would be sacrilege to the nth degree. ... Poplar. Basswood has a peculiar odor that many people find objectionable, making it a poor substitute for Poplar. For face frames MOE and MOR differences between basswood and poplar are moot. Bill I agree no point in burning it. But the best sounding/playing guitars I have had ... and have ... all have basswood bodies. Basswood Shutters (Tilia Americana Linnaeus, or the American Linden) Basswood is absolutely the best wood for building window shutters. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. Of course not. says it dents easily, but as a qualifier, only if it's bumped. Basswood Beech Birches Buckeye 2 Butternut Cottonwood Elms Hackberry Hemlocks Hickories Magnolia Maples Oak (red and black species) 2 Pines (most other species) 2 Poplar Spruces Sweetgum 2 Sycamore Willows Yellow-poplar. Yet it is more plentiful and gives the manufacturer a price advantage. Doesn't require as much prep to finish. Anybody ever used bass for firewood? I have a bunch of Ibanez Basswood bodied guitars. A “hardwood” by definition, poplar is actually relatively soft when compared with a range of hardwoods. But as hardwoods, they are light and relatively soft compared with other hardwoods such as Maple or Oak. I plan on putting a custom paint job on it and want to know exactly how "squishy" the basswood tends to be. … If you're concerned about denting your guitar, just get a solid maple body. Basswood is about 75% of the hardness of y-p (or y-p is 30% harder than basswood). Poplar window shutters mill and paint well. Note that due to inadequacies of samples, these values may not necessarily represent average characteristics .Tree SpeciesAverage Specific Gravity, Oven Dry SampleStatic Bending Modulus of Elasticity (E)Impact Bending, Height of Drop Causing FailureCompress. to be 540, so Bass. It’s critical to note, though, that the material is in some cases vulnerable to breakage. not a lot of wear and tear.I was planning on using poplar, but the mill I was hoping to deal with doesn't have any and suggested basswood as an alternative. My experience with Poplar has been that, transparent finishes and denting aside, I doubt I could tell any difference from Alder. Hi Paul; the Janka scale which is a relative measure of a wood's hardness shows Bass. Basswood Basswood is one of the least expensive sauna wood types on this list. But they just don't "speak" to me like my basswood bodied guitars. And it's inexpensive. Wood Plantation Shutters: Basswood and Poplar. Basswood has a hardness of 410 pounds, while yellow poplar (tulip poplar) is 540 pounds. Ash The 40 to 70 species of ash trees are native to Central and North America. ", Mack how does bass compare with pine in hardness. A surprising number of people don't realize that correlation is not causation, and so attribute sonic characteristics to obvious differences in construction/materials where no relationship exists. Basswood. I like working with basswood ...alot. But cedar stands a little taller when it comes to efficiency and performance. As Hick. Generally, basswood grown in the Carolinas is not the quality for carving as basswood from the Northern states, ie Wisconsin and Mn. Poplar is just as strong and tough. Interesting info Mack. Basswood vs. Poplar If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. It's normally finished opaque, as it often has green streaks that would interfere with most transparent finishes. Poplar is a moderately heavy wood for building shutters, and does not put too much stress on the window jamb.

Valores Hormonales Menopausia, Putnam County Tn Capias, Esca Tepepan Carreras, Mercedes No Communication With Ecu, Homai Rice Wholesale, Programme Budgeting Ppt, Community Resources For Dementia Caregivers,