debunking the electric universe

I'm applying skepticism to the positive statemetns your'e making. With its ‘wolf warrior’ bullying tactics, China fa... SCMP - Beijing moves towards ‘comprehensive jurisd... Coronavirus fatality rate does not justify strong ... SCMP - China-Australia relations: PM Scott Morriso... Turquoise visitor — a Verditer Flycatcher, Watch the Vendee Globe around the world Yacht race. They are posted here in chronological … Continue reading → The FEMA camps are ready; as are the electric collars, guillotines and plastic coffins. You cannot undo discoveries of science, that the universe has a static electrical field its' own, that helps stars fire up & stay lit up. Up to that time, 1,544,661 stories were submitted to Hacker News. Why do air entrainment admixtures improve the freeze-thaw resistance of concrete? Which Type of Bike Would You Select If You Needed To Commute, Ride Fire Roads, and Regular Roads With 1 Bike? Participal plunder: How should ‘animum concentū’ and ‘ex aequō dēmulcēns’ be interpreted? How does this thought experiment not rule out black holes? @Giffyguy, um, that's not what $\Lambda$CDM does. Update the question so it focuses on one problem only by editing this post. While there are many variations to the Electric Universe model, supporters of the theory tend to believe that the cosmology and phenomena found throughout the universe is driven by electricity, rather than … Why are DNS queries using CloudFlare's 1.1.1.1 server timing out? How to draw a table with different braces. Could you describe the electrical theory? The Sun is powered, not from within itself, but from outside, by the electric (Birkeland) currents that flow in our arm of our galaxy as they do in all galaxies. “Electric Universe”, the incredible seven part series from Gaia, offers a limited time opportunity to view the fourth episode absolutely free.Wal Thornhill and Ev Cochrane delve into ancient tales of a goddess with disheveled hair or a head full of snakes that may explain a massive change to our solar system as a new heavenly body joined it.Scroll down to mid-page, center video and watch for FREE Episode 4: “The Birth of Venus”. He doesn't believe in gravity, but rather subscribes to an 'Electrical Theory of the Universe', see the website The Electric Universe. The basic claim of the Electric Universe model is that much of the astronomical phenomena observed in the universe is driven by electrical interactions rather than gravitational ones. If all we see is the sensible world, what are the proofs to affirm that matter exists? This question would definitely be much improved by linking to some resources describing the "electrical theory.". Why are quaternions more popular than tessarines despite being non-commutative? Why do all objects near the Earth fall with the same acceleration? Can a caster cast a sleep spell on themselves? The Jews, themselves, will be the only ones allowed to champion the Ten Commandments. Really, this theory is not even wrong. History repeats itself – and that includes the history of science. when did i say that i believed that? The Electric Universe returns to the highly successful classical method of doing science in the 19 th century. You didn't think flat-earthers had cornered the market on looney tunes, pseudoscientific explanations for how the world works, did you? The Electric Universe theory highlights the importance of electricity throughout the Universe.It is based on the recognition of existing natural electrical phenomena (eg. We are, however, told that the “telescope naming project,” which involved CSIRO staff, Wiradjuri Elders, the NSW Aboriginal Education Consultative Group and various other bodies, required “over two years” of work. I’d never heard of the Electric Universe Theory, but it’s apparently widespread. Plasma cosmology is a non-standard cosmology whose central postulate is that the dynamics of ionized gases and plasmas play important, if not dominant, roles in the physics of the universe beyond the Solar System. So my question is this: Are there any observable behaviors which are inconsistent with the theory's predictions, or are there any demonstrable disproofs for this theory? Readers intrigued by the promise of astronomy being enhanced with, and perhaps superseded by, ancient aboriginal wisdom can partake of. I really appreciate your detailed rebuttals, because it gives me something to track down and research, even if it ends up demonstrating to me why the EU theories are truly indefensible. EDIT: This theory appears to be describing this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasma_cosmology. rev 2021.2.15.38579, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Physics Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. how to perform mathematical operations on numbers in a file using perl or awk? The electric universe “theory” is wrong, full stop. Why not an Electric Theory of Everything? I'm going to do more research on this, and see if I can get any of the PhDs from the Electric Universe community to weigh in on these specific problems. Edit: Sorry for the delay in this, but here's a link to a series of Youtube videos on the electrical theory of the universe (which seems to be the term used by it's proponents, alternatively called the plasma theory). Where I come from, this style of music is regarded as a bit base and far removed from art, but it is of no consequence to those, who take it at face value - a form of audio composition that will pump you full of brainless energy, excitement and enthusiasm. I'm already willing to consider alternatives to dominant models. Bridgman’s postings debunking the “Electric Universe” are ignored by such “theorists” as Wallace Thornhill and Don Scott. First and foremost, it doesn't appear that the electric universe model makes any quantitative predictions. I don't see any models for how stars and galaxies are supposed to form and behave, just a bunch of words about how gravitational models make too many assumptions or … Maybe instead of "electrical theory of the universe" an "electromagnetic theory of the universe" will be more useful. The first are garden-variety physics cranks who are convinced that they have a legitimate, revolutionary scientific theory, and that the scientific establishment is either blindly ignoring them out of misplaced faith in their own theories, or deliberately suppressing them for some greater, nefarious purpose. It adheres to the principles of physics and aims at simplification, in stark distinction to the explosion of imaginary particles and unexplained forces of the last century. Every Wednesday at 11am Pacific – 2pm Eastern – 19:00 GMT. @Giffyguy: great. Original Post February 2, 2012. From my cursory overview of the stuff these people have online, there are a few really glaring problems: This list is hardly exhaustive, but these are a few starting points. The visible universe is static and much smaller than we thought. I don't see any models for how stars and galaxies are supposed to form and behave, just a bunch of words about how gravitational models make too many assumptions or rely on too much theory, whatever that means. They need to explain how they resolve Olbers' paradox. Any attempt by a Gentile to follow the customs and traditions of the Jews will once again be met with heavy persecution, imprisonment and death by beheading. The vacuum chamber enables an electric discharge to be created, not too dissimilar from that created in a fluorescent light. Which of these theories on why light slows in media are true? Should a high elf wizard use weapons instead of cantrips? You seemed to be attacking my assertion that only an idiot would believe the water for gas crap. The resulting properties are measured with a wide variety of diagnostics, in… Electric universe theory says that the solar wind is the result of such a field, and the Sun is electric, not fusion based. Came across the EUT via David Thompson’s blog, reporting on the renaming of Australia’s iconic Parkes Telescope — made famous by transmitting the first pix from the moon in 1969. If you're going to use electricity to explain gravity, you need to explain why the rate at which something falls is independent of that object's charge (minus electric self-force), and also independent of that object's mass. Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. The Big Bang didn’t happen. The solar discharge has a very effective feedback system to maintain steady radiant output while the electrical power input varies. How can we feel the effects of a Black Hole if all the mass is gone? I'll let you know if I find anything interesting. Plasma cosmology doesn't predict Hubble's Law, the relative abundances of the elements or the cosmic microwave background. https://www.everythingselectric.com/electric-universe-debunked Point me to a calculation where the electric universe calculates the relative helium abundance correctly in the absence of dark matter. Debunking the “Electric Universe Theory” Click above to go to video: How did I miss this one? [link to www.electric-universe.info] is scientists collectively debunking commonly held beliefs about the universe electrical aspects.Try [link to www.jmaccanneyscience.com] also, an astrophysicist proving the electrical discharges when comets … It's a big red flag when science journals all reject your stuff. He doesn’t, Paul Krugman, the Lock-’Em-Down Economist, The case against Trump. The Electric Universe Theory Debunked The Electric Universe Acid Test » Michael Shermer Testing the Electric Universe Therefore, it doesn’t matter what the EU “theory” says about black holes. Is it bad practice to git init in the $home directory to keep track of dot files? Debunking the 'Electric Universe' Of all the characters propagating space-related scams on the internet, by far the most damaging is Ben Davidson and his channel Suspicious0bservers. Why does an oscillating electric field couple more strongly to electrons than to ions? Electric Universe is definitely top of the shelf when it comes to psychedelic trance. How to debunk 'The Electric Universe'? Also, it appears that these models don't really discuss the equivalence principle. There’s a cosmological model that has gained popularity on the internet known as the Electric Universe. So its promoters publish it themselves, on the Internet and in self-published books. I remember! If you are wondering what is Plasma Cosmology then this person on the Physics Forums writes about this thoughts on its ideology and concepts compared or related to the Big Bang theory.. Beijing expects Canberra to make first move to rep... "The government simply doesn't understand the diff... Lost in translation: don’t mock the boy with the ‘... How the national security law draws Hong Kong clos... SCMP - Hong Kong deserves a civil service that mov... ‘ China to Halt Key Australian Imports in Sweeping... Sam Harris thinks he finally gets Trump. @JerrySchirmer You know what, I apologize if I offended you (or insulted your work) with the preachy YouTube video and my other comments (I deleted them because I am currently unprepared to defend them). The second group is composed of various other woo-peddlers who use EU claims to prop up their main ideas (because mainstream physics would blow them apart). I know it's almost certainly incorrect - extraordinary claims requiring extraordinary evidence and all - but I can't demonstrate it. I found the question interesting because physicists extrapolate to the universe in general from their measurements of the behavior of electromagnetic beams. In particular, the standard $\Lambda$CDM models very precisely predict the relative abundance of hydrogen and helium in our universe. Maxwell’s theory of acceleration, however, talks about a time variable field, not a fixed one, and what’s more the solar wind contains both positive … Is it possible for one side of the universe to “meet” the other? Back in 1879, the very notion of ‘prehistoric cave art’ was unheard of. Synopsis 2 – The ELECTRIC UNIVERSE ... And the Sun and the solar system are threaded by magnetic fields, which signify electric current flows. Seriously, how can this model pass both solar system tests and explain galactic dynamics, AND predict the correct helium abundance? In its strongest version it denies the existence of Gravity! First and foremost, it doesn't appear that the electric universe model makes any quantitative predictions. [closed], Opt-in alpha test for a new Stacks editor, Visual design changes to the review queues. Reading time: 11 minutes We’ve all heard of far-fetched things made up by pretend-skeptics as a seeming alternative to 170+ years of well-established physics (the radiative physics of greenhouse gases). site design / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. lightning, St Elmo’s Fire), and the known properties of plasmas (ionized “gases”) which make up 99.999% of the visible universe, and react strongly to electro-magnetic fields. The Electric Universe. There was no Big Bang. Is an electric field a transverse wave not in a vacuum? Out of curiosity, how does the electrical theory of the universe explain the behaviour of 3 seperated bodies/point particles, which all attract each other? Of those stories, 6,826 have been identified as evergreen. Well, we pop that thought balloon this week as we delve into the world of the Electric Universe. Is this copyright or am I allowed to have this in my math textbook? Was there a Big Switch On or Big Turn On instead of a Big Bang? A Growing US Left _on ECONOMIC UPDATE with Richard D. Wolff “Updates on California events (LA Times labor union, 80,000 Kaiser workers to strike, new state public banking law), gross inefficiency of private car industry, anti-left politics in US labor history, wide global use of wealth taxes vs “conservative” claims. My father is a generally intelligent person, however he has latched onto a theory which I believe to be completely incorrect. Nothing about the Electric Universe has been published in scientific journals, because it can't pass peer review. Electric Universe. Things related to the theories or ideas of Plasma Cosmology are … EU advocates can be roughly split into two groups. Physics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for active researchers, academics and students of physics. Want to improve this question? a p.s. Support For The Electric Universe Model. Simple implementation of the abs function by getting rid of or by consuming the "-"? The chamber contains an electrode, usually a ball-shaped positively-charged anode, surrounded by a cathode. Debunking Misconceptions About the Electric Universe (Leave ... Mythscape was produced before the convergence of Saturn theory with Wal Thornhill and the Electric Universe and provides an historical context for the more recent production of Symbols of an Alien Sky. You can look up the "electromagnetic worldview" and Max Abraham for some pointers. to this would be that all 20th century particle physics data is ignored by this proposed "theory", standard model and all. 25 February 2014. It is essentially discredited by relativity, which ruled out mechanical ethers. Is it realistic for a town to completely disappear overnight without a major crisis? While dark matter and dark energy are problems, they solve problems that arise within a quantitative model. Show me that link, rather than some preachy youtube article about skepticism. Benchmark test that was used to characterize an 8-bit CPU? Beijing’s lates... SCMP - Coronavirus hunters pick up another piece o... "Unable to contain the outbreak of joy”... SCMP - Last thing world hit by coronavirus needs i... Why has China done so well controlling the virus? I've looked into it enough to realize that it flies completely in the face of current physics models, but I'm not qualified to debunk it. What evidence can I present against it? “Hong Kong pan-democrats who quit Legco showed nei... “We must all soldier on together if coronavirus ba... SCMP - To stay in Hong Kong or go? We have no idea of the age or extent of the universe. It only takes a minute to sign up. We know nothing of the origin of the universe. The universe is static… Varying the gas mixture, pressure, voltage and current (direct current), facilitates various kinds of plasma discharges. And the existing cosmological models come at the relative abundance of dark matter using various methodologies, all of which predict the same result. How old is the Electric Universe? This resource contains all evergreen stories posted to Hacker News through November 7th, 2014. TL;DR - all of that crap you learned in school was wrong and the root of every force in the universe is electricity. I'm just not willing to consider crap. The particulars of that “astronomical knowledge,” also referred to as “ancient wisdom,” and its bearing on modern radio astronomy, are, alas, not shared in the press release. If the 'electric' universe can't do that, then it has a bigger problem than dark matter/dark energy, Also, these people seem to believe in an eternal static universe with an infinite extent. It is a small additional … Plasma Cosmology debunked – list of articles, forum threads, evidence, blogs arguing that the Plasma Cosmology theory is wrong. F… The case against Biden. In the Plasma Universe model these currents create the galaxies and the stars within them.

Housing Grievance Policy, Among Us Song Tiktok Lyrics, Love Island Game Season 2 Challenge Answers, Movie Theater San Clemente, Dj Jimmy Jatt Net Worth, Fortnite Hacks 2020, Weapon Fusion Generator,